April 22, 2009

The Large Hadron Collider (LHC) is the world’s largest atom smasher. It will accelerate hadrons (protons) to nearly the speed of light forcing them to collide head-on. These collisions will produce greater concentrations of energy than have existed in nature since the first trillionth of a second of the universe, the Big Bang. That at least was a claim being floated around by proponents throughout the funding and construction phases of the project. Now that the interest of the public has shifted from funding to safety, that claim is downplayed and is replaced by assurances that the planned collisions are safe and routine. What’s the way it is?
Read the rest of this entry »
4 Comments |
Science and Nature |
Permalink
Posted by John
December 27, 2008

Splenda (sucralose) has overtaken Equal (aspartame) in the artificial sweetener market thanks to a marketing campaign that claims Splenda is closely related to sugar and is by implication safer and less artificial. Splenda’s slogan “Made from Sugar. So it tastes like sugar.” can be found on every packet and appears in every ad. But that claim is misleading and was even the subject of a highly publicized lawsuit. Should advertisers be permitted to take advantage of gullible consumers by making misleading claims, even if those claims are based on truth?
Read the rest of this entry »
1 Comment |
Science and Nature |
Permalink
Posted by John
December 14, 2008
Eighteen year old South African track athlete Caster Semenya has stirred up a storm of controversy lately through no fault of her own. Semenya won the 800-meter race at the world championships in Berlin with a world record time. Semenya is an extraordinary athlete in many ways. In addition to her remarkable record, she has the misfortune of having some fairly obvious masculine features. It’s a misfortune in this case anyway because it has caused her sex to be questioned and subject to review by the IAAF (International Association of Athletics Federations). The issue is whether it’s fair to allow her to compete in women’s events if she is suspected to be a man.
Semenya has been raised as a woman and her family and friends vehemently reject suggestions that she is not. While the IAAF attempted to conduct their investigation in private, it has turned out to be very public, and Semenya has been subjected to sensationalism and embarrassment in the process. The serious privacy issues involved should probably overshadow the facts of the matter, but the public’s lack of understanding of sex is easier to discuss objectively.
It appears that Semenya is one of a large portion of the population (possibly as many as 1 of every 2000 people) that is intersex, not perfectly100% normal male or female, but in some way in between. In fact there are so many ways to be intersex and various degrees of each that there really is not definitive way to define who’s a male or a female. The public has a hard time with such things. They want there to be a simple either-or test. Unfortunately it’s not really a practical thing to determine.
The recent controversy over in California’s Prop 8 (constitutionally prohibiting same sex marriage) brings up an interesting academic question. If one’s sex determines their constitutional rights, such as who they can marry, it’s critical that we can easily and definitively determine someone’s sex. Is this really possible or practical?
Leave a Comment » |
Science and Nature |
Permalink
Posted by John